The revival of planning for a downtown subway began with the 2008 publication of Metrolinx’s regional transportation plan, the Big Move, which foresaw the need for a “U” shaped subway running from an undetermined station along the Danforth section of the Bloor-Danforth line, south-west through downtown with connections with the Yonge and University subways, and north-west towards an undetermined station along the western section of the Bloor-Danforth line.8
Planned to be implemented within 25 years, plans for the line were accelerated as support from municipal and transit officials grew, and as capacity issues along the existing Yonge subway which the proposed line would help relieve worsened.9 Updates to the regional transportation plan were undertaken in 2013 which reprioritized the core section of the project running from a station along the University subway to a station along the Bloor-Danforth line to be completed within 15 years.10
The proposed subway, dubbed the Downtown Relief Line because of its projected effect on providing relief to capacity strains on existing subway infrastructure, underwent studies for potential alignments starting in 2012 with the TTC’s Downtown Rapid Transit Expansion Study, with further refinement in 2014 with the start of the Relief Line Project Assessment undertaken by the City of Toronto and the TTC.11
A breakthrough in the planning of the Relief Line came in March 2016, with the identification and approval of a preferred corridor by Toronto city council.12 The corridor, running from Pape Station to downtown Toronto using Pape Avenue and Queen or Richmond Streets was chosen because of its positive effects on several aspects considered: serving a wide range of destinations, connectivity with other transit initiatives, promotion of social equity, and lowest potential cost.13
An alignment within the corridor was eventually selected and approved by council in May 2017, with a line running from Pape Station to Osgoode Station via Pape Avenue, Carlaw Avenue, Eastern Avenue, and Queen Street and stations at Osgoode Station, Queen Station, Sherbourne Street, Sumach Street, Broadview Avenue, Carlaw Avenue, Gerrard Street, and Pape Station.14 Besides interchanges with the Yonge-University and Bloor-Danforth lines at the existing Osgoode, Queen, and Pape Stations, stations with connections to future SmartTrack and GO Regional Express Rail services were planned at stations at Broadview Avenue and Gerrard Street.15